Cultural Adaptations to Empirically Supported Treatments: a Research Agenda
نویسنده
چکیده
The movement to establish uniform standards for the identification of empirically supported treatments (EST) has contributed to an impressive growth in the number of treatments deemed to have strong evidence of their efficacy. Those treatments meeting the most rigorous standards are often granted the label well-established and have been identified in a variety of online and print formats. An important criticism of the EST movement is the fact that the overwhelming majority of treatments identified as well-established have limited evidence of their generalizability to participants from different cultural groups. One approach to addressing this limitation has been the development and evaluation of cultural adaptations of these treatments. Although the emerging evidence frequently documents the efficacy of cultural adaptations, many questions remain. In this article, I examine the several issues related to the development and evaluation of cultural adaptations of empirically supported treatments. Specifically, I address the following questions: (1) What information should inform whether and when to adapt an existing treatment for a particular racial, ethnic, or cultural group? (2) How should cultural adaptations be made to an existing treatment? And finally, (3) how should a culturally adapted treatment be empirically evaluated?
منابع مشابه
Cultural competence and evidence-based practice in mental health services: a complementary perspective.
The need for cultural competence and the need for evidence-based practice in mental health services are major issues in contemporary discourse, especially in the psychological treatment of people of color. Although these 2 paradigms are complementary in nature, there is little cross-fertilization in the psychological literature. The present article illustrates the complementary nature of these ...
متن کاملEmpirically supported treatments in pediatric psychology: where is the diversity?
OBJECTIVE To examine the extent to which studies used to support empirically supported treatments for asthma, cancer, diabetes, and obesity address issues of cultural diversity. METHOD We chose original articles (71) of treatments used to support empirically supported treatments (ESTs) published as part of a special series on ESTs in the Journal of Pediatric Psychology. Trained coders reviewe...
متن کاملThe Complexity of Culture: Do We Embrace the Challenge or Avoid It?
This article responds to the comments of La Roche and Lustig (2010), O’Donohue and Benuto (2010), Ollendick, Lewis, and Fraire (2010), Sue (2010), and Stuart (2010) on the author’s original article (Cardemil, 2010) that examined several issues related to the development and evaluation of cultural adaptations of empirically supported treatments. Although the comments were varied in their reactio...
متن کاملCommentary on Integrating Cognitive-Behavioral and Cognitive-Interpersonal Case Formulations: A Case Study of a Chinese American Male Being Culturally Sensitive is Not the Same as Being Culturally Competent
Empirically supported treatments have been found to be effective for psychiatric problems among Caucasian American clients. However, there continues to be little research conducted on the efficacy of such treatments when used with ethnic minority clients. Liu (2007) does an excellent job in using cognitive-behavioral and cognitive-interpersonal case formulations to develop an effective treatmen...
متن کاملDevelopmental factors in the treatment of adolescents.
Most empirically supported interventions for adolescent mental health problems are either downward adaptations of adult treatments or upward adaptations of child treatments. Although these treatments show respectable effects with teens, a review of the outcome research reveals significant gaps. both in coverage of adolescent conditions and problems (e.g., eating disorders, suicidality) and in a...
متن کامل